UK eCommerce returns are no longer a side issue; they are one of the biggest line items eroding contribution margin in fashion, footwear and other high-return categories. In a market where online return rates frequently sit around 20–25%, UK retailers are absorbing growing logistics, processing and duty costs just to stand still on revenue. For CFOs and controllers, the question is no longer “how to live with returns” but “how to recover cash from them without adding operational friction.”
Q1: the real returns season
The UK experiences a pronounced “returns season” immediately after the year-end sales peak, with January and early Q1 showing some of the highest return volumes of the year. Some operators reported January returns spikes of more than 40% year-on-year, turning warehouses and 3PL facilities into de‑facto reverse logistics hubs. For finance leaders, that means a disproportionate share of annual return-related write-offs, handling costs and lost margin hit the P&L in Q1 rather than being evenly spread through the year.
Beyond volume, Q1 returns tie up working capital at the worst possible moment: after peak-season inventory investments and promotional discounts. Returned stock often sits in limbo while teams reconcile customer refunds, refurbish items and decide whether goods can be resold domestically or must be re‑exported. Without a structured approach to reclaiming import duties on items that leave the UK again, a significant portion of that capital simply never comes back.
How UK returns impact duties
Every imported order that is later returned has an invisible cost layer: customs duties and, in many cases, import VAT paid when the goods first entered the UK. When those items are refunded and re‑exported to a non‑UK destination or to a central EU warehouse, the original import duties effectively become pure expense. Across high‑volume apparel and footwear eCommerce, this quickly adds up to six or seven figures of annual “returns duty leakage” that most P\&L views do not separate from overall returns cost.
UK and EU customs frameworks recognise that this situation is economically inefficient, which is why mechanisms exist to avoid paying duty twice on the same goods. When merchandise is imported, then exported again in the same or essentially unaltered condition, the duties associated with those goods can often be relieved or reclaimed, provided specific conditions are met. For Q1’s tidal wave of returns, these rules represent a material opportunity to reverse part of the cost that finance teams currently treat as irreversible.
Duty drawback and returned goods
In customs terms, reclaiming import duties on goods that are later exported or re‑exported is commonly known as duty drawback, although this terminology is more appropriate to the US context. This regime is designed so that imports that ultimately leave the customs territory again are not permanently burdened with duties, as long as the goods are returned in the same state apart from limited permitted handling.
For eCommerce retailers, that means that many refunded orders shipped back from UK customers, then consolidated and re‑exported to EU hubs or other markets, are potential candidates for duty recovery. The key is to demonstrate that the specific items being re‑exported are the same as the ones originally imported, that they have not been upgraded or transformed, and that they move back out of the UK within the time limits set by HMRC.
The critical three‑month window
Timing is essential: the solution promoted here focuses on reclaiming UK import duties on goods that are returned within three months of the original sale. In fast‑moving eCommerce, that 3 month window typically covers the bulk of fashion and sporting-goods returns driven by post‑holiday sizing issues, buyer’s remorse and promotion‑driven impulse purchases.
When finance teams capture and structure data on returns that fall inside this three‑month period, they create a clean subset of transactions ideally suited to a duty drawback program. This enables focused claims that are easier to support with evidence, drive meaningful recovery per shipment, and can be repeated quarter after quarter as part of a systematic returns‑to‑refunds engine rather than a one‑off project.
Getting declarations right
Duty recovery on returned goods does not happen automatically: it depends on how both the original import and the subsequent export declarations are structured. On top of commodity codes, origin, customs value and any special procedures, references to the orders must be correctly declared to establish the duty paid and link it to specific consignments and products. If the importation was not fully documented in CDS, TDR experts team
Supporting records, such as order and shipment IDs, customer returns data, carrier tracking and warehouse receipts need to be consistent so that auditors can trace each SKU from first import through return and final export.
Why Q1 is the moment to act
Because Q1 concentrates such a high share of return volume, adjustments made now have an outsized impact on the full financial year. Finance teams that map Q1 returns against import records and begin building eligible duty reclaim files can convert a seasonal costs spike into an early‑year cash injection.
Operationally, warehouses and 3PLs are already segmenting returned stock by condition, channel and disposition during this period. Adding a customs‑driven lens—marking items for re‑export and potential drawback fits naturally into existing return-handling workflows, especially when supported by a specialist partner and clear data requirements.
TDR’s streamlined reclaim process
Trade Duty Refund has developed a dedicated, low‑friction process to help UK importers reclaim duties on returned eCommerce goods with minimal disruption to existing operations. The approach starts with a diagnostic of your import, returns and export data to identify high‑yield lanes and SKUs where duty paid is significant and re‑exports are frequent within the three‑month window
Once the opportunity is quantified, TDR connects import entries, outbound orders, customer returns and re‑exports into structured claim files that meet HMRC expectations, while working alongside your existing brokers, 3PLs and platforms rather than replacing them. A contingent-fee model keeps internal budget impact low, with TDR remunerated on recovered duties rather than fixed consulting days, aligning incentives with finance’s focus on measurable payback.
Minimising operational impact
A common concern for CFOs is that duty reclaim projects will overload internal teams or require significant systems change. TDR’s process is designed to sit on top of your current tech stack—ERP, OMS, WMS, eCommerce platforms—using data extracts and existing customs documentation rather than large IT projects.
Expert readiness assessment
Not every retailer is ready to file a robust duty refund claim on day one, which is why TDR’s team starts with an eligibility and readiness assessment. TDR provides the option of a 2-minute online preliminary questionnaire or a short live discussion. This review looks at your customs broker setup, the consistency of your import and export declarations, and the completeness of order, shipment and returns data needed to substantiate claims.
Where gaps exist, for example, missing links between export declarations and original import entries, TDR recommends targeted fixes that improve both compliance and refund potential. For finance leaders, that translates into a clear view of “money left on the table,” a roadmap to unlock it, and confidence that any claims submitted stand up to HMRC scrutiny.
Turning returns into an advantage
In a market where UK online return rates are among the highest globally and refunds represent the majority of returns outcomes, retailers that treat duties on returned imports as recoverable, not sunk, will enjoy a structural margin advantage. Competitors who accept returns as a fixed cost will continue to feel pressure on unit economics, particularly in Q1 when volumes and duty leakage peak.
By pairing a customer-friendly returns strategy with a disciplined duty reclaim program, finance leaders can both protect loyalty and recapture part of the cost of generosity. With specialist support from Trade Duty Refund, now is the moment to turn the UK returns spike from a drag on profitability into a repeatable, data‑driven source of recovered cash.
Resources: